Brewers 3B Luis Urias' diving catch in NLDS vs Braves was unreviewable - so can we fix replay? by @CloseCallSports - Post Details

Brewers 3B Luis Urias' diving catch in NLDS vs Braves was unreviewable - so can we fix replay?

When Milwaukee retired Atlanta batter Adam Duvall on a foul fly ball in Game 4 of the NLDS, Brian Snitker wanted to challenge the play. But we foresaw a problem - infield catch calls are not reviewable. Article: https://www.closecallsports.com/2021/10/brewers-braves-nlds-replays-infield-fly.html When HP Umpire Tony Randazzo's out call went to New York, the outcome of that conversation was apparent from Crew Chief Alfonso Marquez's action afterward. By removing the headset, giving no mechanic or other indication as to what the call was, and traveling directly toward the Braves' dugout to speak with manager Snitker, it was clear that the play had not been reviewed. Instead, the official record chalks it up to a rules check on an unreviewable play which means the out call (catch), not subject to review, didn't stand, didn't get confirmed, nor overturned, but simply was left untouched by video.

Similar Posts!

E26 - Umpire Denies ABS Challenge, Miguel Cairo Ejected by Carlos Torres in Really Dumb Sequence
E26 - Umpire Denies ABS Challenge, Miguel Cairo Ejected by Carlos Torres in Really Dumb Sequence

HP Umpire Carlos Torres ejected Orioles infield coach Miguel Cairo for arguing a denied ABS challenge to Baltimore catcher Samuel Basallo for taking too long to challenge? Kind of? This sequence was so problematic, it had me defending MIGUEL CAIRO. Report: https://www.closecallsports.com/2026/05/mlb-ejection-026-carlos-torres-2-miguel.html Buy Me a Coffee: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/closecallsports Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/Lindsay715 Discord: https://discord.gg/eFXWr7yHWM Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/CloseCallSports Twitter: https://twitter.com/CloseCallSports



E19 - Wacha's Wardrobe Malfunction w Pitch Clock Expiring Leads to Uncalled Quick Pitch, Ejection
E19 - Wacha's Wardrobe Malfunction w Pitch Clock Expiring Leads to Uncalled Quick Pitch, Ejection

HP Umpire John Libka ejected Athletics hitting coach Chris Cron for arguing a quick pitch no-call as Kansas City's Michael ...



Cubs' Fair Ball in San Diego: Padres Perplexed at Umpire Merzel's Call as Ty France Thought it Foul
Cubs' Fair Ball in San Diego: Padres Perplexed at Umpire Merzel's Call as Ty France Thought it Foul

Cubs batter Matt Shaw hit an infield single in San Diego when Padres 3B Ty France picked up a batted ball as it rolled along the foul line, but HP Umpire Dan Merzel called it fair. So... was it fair or foul? Turns out, this play is a lot more complicated than it should be. https://www.closecallsports.com/2026/04/about-cubs-lf-matt-shaws-fair-infield.html Buy Me a Coffee: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/closecallsports Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/Lindsay715 Discord: https://discord.gg/eFXWr7yHWM Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/CloseCallSports Twitter: https://twitter.com/CloseCallSports



E161-2 - Pete Walker & John Schneider Ejected as Blue Jays Lose 20-1 Blowout to Royals
E161-2 - Pete Walker & John Schneider Ejected as Blue Jays Lose 20-1 Blowout to Royals

HP Umpire James Jean ejected Blue Jays pitching coach Pete Walker for arguing a ball four call to Maikel Garcia & 3B Umpire ...



Fan Interference AND Home Run? Blue Jays Baffled by Replay's HR Call as Umpires Say Both Happened
Fan Interference AND Home Run? Blue Jays Baffled by Replay's HR Call as Umpires Say Both Happened

Rays batter Brandon Lowe's home run stood on Replay Review as umpires called both fan interference & a home run on the ...



E134 - Miguel Cairo Ejected After Nationals Nearly Give Up Lead to Mets, Todd Tichenor Calls a Ball
E134 - Miguel Cairo Ejected After Nationals Nearly Give Up Lead to Mets, Todd Tichenor Calls a Ball

HP Umpire Todd Tichenor ejected Nationals manager Miguel Cairo for arguing a ball two call to Mark Vientos after the Mets ...



E130-1 - Yankees & Cardinals Ejected on Hot St Louis Day as Swanson & Marmol Get Tossed by Vic & Nic
E130-1 - Yankees & Cardinals Ejected on Hot St Louis Day as Swanson & Marmol Get Tossed by Vic & Nic

3B Umpire Vic Carapazza ejected Yankees coach Tanner Swanson and HP Umpire Nic Lentz ejected Cardinals manager Oliver ...



E125 - Alex Cora Ejected on Balk No-Call by Ryan Blakney as Boston Doesn't Know Windup vs Set Rule
E125 - Alex Cora Ejected on Balk No-Call by Ryan Blakney as Boston Doesn't Know Windup vs Set Rule

HP Umpire Ryan Blakney ejected Red Sox manager Alex Cora for arguing that Astros pitcher Hunter Brown balked by switching ...